Or, will Horstmann be the next star of The Bachelor 2019?
Blake, ever the gentleman, told Becca she had nothing to say sorry for and that he wanted her to be happy.
"But I feel like she knew who I was as a person, and that I didn't stand by those likes; and that I was a better person than I was presenting on my social media", Garrett said.
The rejection: It's a credit to the producers that they were able to keep us guessing (or at least some of us) until nearly the final moment, when the man she was about to reject stepped out of a motorboat onto the beach. Garrett says he doesn't have butterflies around Becca, because butterflies are too small. She also said that, because their connection was so solid, she may have overlooked other relationships. I went on the Bachelorette for the adventure and possibility of falling in love, not fame.
She told Yrigoyen he was the first guy who she wrote about in her journal and that he reminded her of her dad.
Becca and Garrett both shared on the After the Final Rose special that their hometown date is where things really solidified for them. "I know it's going to be insane when that moment comes, but it's going to be so worth it and so I'm going to be so excited for that day". "We wish Becca all the happiness in the world". "I didn't mean to offend anyone".
Just hours after Becca's Bachelorette premiere, it came to light that Garrett had a history of "liking" offensive social media posts, which included memes mocking transgender people, liberal women, and school shooting survivors. "It makes our relationship so much stronger, and we continue to grow together".
The future: When the proposal finally came it nearly seemed like an afterthought given how long we had to wait to see it (although I understand why the producers wouldn't have made Blake sit and watch it). Luckily, I got to know him for who he is. "I was very anxious about it, that I might lose her from that".
"Just because I liked it, doesn't necessarily mean that I supported it", he told PEOPLE.
"I know that he stands by his apology and he feels so bad for everyone that he did offend and he didn't mean it". But all I could ask for is somebody who owns up to what they've done and who apologizes and wants to grow.
This ethos was reiterated by Becca: "It's been a constant conversation, and he's had to deal with really negative things being said about him - awful things".
Yrigoyen, a Reno, Nevada-based medical sales representative, 29, dropped down on one knee and asked for Kufrin's hand in marriage after Kufrin said three magic words.
Garrett said he was "really worried" when the reports starting dropping online, adding that he thought "I might lose her from that".